Kids’ thoughts on Climate Change

We’ve been spending much of our time on Fridays reading about and discussing jtopics related to Climate change. We’ve looked at waste and recycling. We’ve explored questions we have about all the terms that come up  like fossil fuels and the greenhouse effect. We have found some helpful information, but we also keep coming up with new questions.

It is interesting (asn sometimes confusing) that so many different topics, ideas and opinions come up when we talk about Climate Change. I think it is important, especially given how heated discussions on this topic can become, that we make it a habit to be curious about what others are thinking and feeling. And if I am going to ask students to be curious about others’ thoughts, I think I should begin by showing that I am interested in what students are thinking and feeling.

So, I am asking: what do you think about most when you think about Climate Change; how does it make you feel; what questions do you still have; and what action do you think you should take?

Comments and responses are welcome. 

WASTE!

Single use surfboards!?

We’ve been looking at problems we face on our planet and most recently have been looking into waste. I was reminded of a Yogi Bear cartoon I saw decades ago in which the gang visited a tropical island whose lone inhabitant treated it like a land of plenty. On Mr Waste’s island, the wastefulness is over-the-top. Yogi’s gang are expected to throw things away after using them only once or after consuming just a small amount. For example, they will eat just one bite of a banana & throw the rest away. They are told to get a new surfboard after riding just one wave on the old one and to get new clothes after wearing (or even just trying on) an outfit once. It is SO bad, and seems SO unrealistic that it is absurd. It’s silly. It makes us groan, roll our eyes, & laugh. It’s ludicrous. No one would actually be so ridiculously wasteful.

Yet, here are some ways that real people in the real world are wasteful in ways that are EVEN WORSE than what seemed like absurdly silly examples used to demonstrate a simple (and seemingly obvious) moral lesson in a cartoon:

  • shark finning (cutting the fins off live sharks to sell for a profit, tossing the rest of the dying animal into the ocean, and destroying the balance of ocean ecosystems by removing a top predator https://science.sciencemag.org/content/315/5820/1846; http://therevolutionmovie.com/index.php/open-your-eyes/overfishing/intro/ )Shark fins
  • leaving nearly half of the celery a farmer grows on the ground so that what goes to the grocery store will fit in the PLASTIC bags used by the company buying it from the farmer. http://www.foodwastemovie.com/video/
  • being fussy about what produce looks like in the store. People who grow their own vegetables are likely to marvel briefly at the sometimes oddly-shaped vegetables their plants may produce before chopping them up to be eaten. At the store, shoppers scour the large piles of produce for perfect specimens to spend their money on. Not only does this mean that imperfect fruit & vegetables in the store won’t be purchased (& will likely be thrown out), but in this way WE CONSUMERS tell the stores to tell the farmers not to even send imperfect produce to the store because we won’t buy it. WE are thus telling farmers to use more resources (water, land, fertiliser…) so they can grow so much produce that the fraction of it that looks perfect will be enough to meet our demand (never mind all the perfectly good food that will be thrown away or the water & labour that will have been used for nothing).
  • monoculture farming. To make farming efficient by getting a large crop using the least labour, we plant huge fields of just one variety of plant. This depletes soil, requiring extra fertiliser. The concentration of one type of plant attracts large numbers of critters that like to eat them, which leads to widespread use of large quantities of pesticides to protect farmers’ crops (and profits), which is leading to the depletion of insect species, reduction of biodiversity, and is threatening the survival of pollinators like bees on which we depend for a third of the food we eat! Those pesticides & fertilisers also end up getting washed into waterways & oceans where they affect those habitats & ecosystems and are significantly responsible for ocean acidification.
  • not walking. pollution leading to ocean acidification threatening life in the oceans including zooplankton on which we depend for oxygen.
  • shopping. overpackaging (use of resources, unnecessary waste, plastic), buying new (transportation, shipping, pollution, unnecessary deman

Reduce food waste (13914380453)

Can you find more ways we are being wasteful?

Should we eat harp seal?

yes:

I think it’s OK to eat harp seal because we don’t harm their population(talk about:4.0 – 6.4 million in the Northwest Atlantic population, 300,000 in the east Greenland population, and 1.2 million in the Barents Sea / White Sea population) and some people like to try something new so it can be a good serving,Also The government allows harvesting seals.The restaurant serves seal on special holidays and it’s located on Vancouver island, many cultures are allowed to have harp seal.Harp seal are very plentiful.

monthly                                  yearly
approximate  3,200                      400,000

no:

The Inuit takes every part of the animal/ mammal,(even the eyes) but if the restaurant just takes the meat then they’re not using every part of its nature’s food source.  one time in music Ms.Con talked about this restaurant and there’s this one soup that’s called shark fin soup but what they do is, they’ll cut the fin off and throw the shark back in the water.                                                                                                                    I didn’t understand why would they do that just for the fin but they’re not using anything else other than that. Harp seals have families too, and we are treating them differently as if you are not the same as them or there are just animals/mammals, also I personally think some people don’t care about things like the climate change.

My Thinking:

I think I’m more on the no side because, If you harm their population soon scientists say that in 2045 the whole society will be into eating harp seal so that’s really bad and soon after that they might go extinct.My thinking is why do we kill harp seals when they have a family and so do we, I think if everyone stops and take a look at what we’re doing then we will be more formative to the world.

I personally think that harp seals are very cute animals/mammals because they are completely harmless and if you’ve seen them you can see how they like humans, at the same time you will like them too! “have you ever pet one before?” my friend told me.                                                                                                                      I hadn’t but you might be able to see them at the Vancouver aquarium, even though my friend said if I ever petted one in my life or your just saying that because their cute but climate change is what’s happening right now so we have to stop pollution for the cause of this planet and others.

I honor them because I don’t want harp seals to go extinct and that we will have to find another food source that we can eat. if I have the right to say this then you do too, so why won’t you stand up for this planet!