I personally think Cole should be sent to jail! He smashed peter driskols skull into the side walk! Cole was also mean and threatening. Cole threatened peter, “your a dead man,” touching spirit bear page 7.Cole was taking it out on the spirit Bear, “A bear with half a brain would have turned tail and run. Instead this dumb animal had attacked.”, he thought. Page 69
Cole wanted to take it out on the baby sparrows.”if I where the mother I would leave them to fend for themselves”,he thought.”She didn’t ow them anything”.”Without his injuries he could have crawled up and and knocked the nest down”,” that what the stupid birds deserved”he thought. Page 75
The parts of the text you quoted do show Cole’s hard-hearted callousness, even after arriving on the island. Cole’s words and actions make it easy to appreciate why members of the circle might argue that it is most important to protect public safety.
Garvey is a Parole officer whose job is part of the legal system put in place to help do just that. Why ever would a person in that position suggest anything other than jail?