-I think banishing Cole was a good idea, because when he saw the spirit bear he tried to kill it.

-And he spoke when he din’t have the white feather.

-He lied about trusting and joining the circle justice about healing.

-He also burned the sack on the island with all the supplies in it.

-He tired escaping the island but instead the waves pushed him back to the island , and that’s when he saw the spirit bear.

-Cole hit Peter hard, until Peter was seriously injured.

-Cole and Peter met at the hearing justice because Cole beat Peter.

-Cole did’t even try to be good, instead he keeps on trying to escape.

Banishment is better than a jail cell, and it doesn’t bring any good. letting Cole into nature and letting him be by himself  is a better way of letting him learn. His dad and mom don’t really care about him so thats why he is acting like a not trained person. He has actually punched peter before.

And Garvey had always told him that:”what you do to the animals, you do to yourself,remember that”.Cole always thought that was crazy and he did’t get what Garvey meant.But maybe  until he and the spirit bear had attacked, he might learn a lesson.